tv Washington Journal Brad Carson CSPAN September 21, 2026 5:38pm-6:39pm EDT
5:38 pm
on president trump speech to the u.n. with the executive director director of the mccain institute , evelyn farkas. c-span's washington journal. join in the conversation at 7:00 eastern tuesday morning on c-span, c-span now, our free mobile app, or online at c-span.org. >> this wednesday, it is congress versus the press. watch the congressional women's softball game as members of congress and the washington, d.c. press corps battle it out on the softball field all to raise money and awareness for breast cancer. catch the action wednesday at 7:30 p.m. eastern on c-span, c-span now, our free mobile video app, or online at c-span.org. c-span, democracy unfiltered. >> we returned to the topic of artificial intelligence, the government's role in regulating it. our guess is former oklahoma
5:39 pm
democratic congressman brad carson who currently serves as president of americans for responsible innovation, a nonprofit that you founded in 2023 to steer ai policy in the right direction. what is the right direction for ai policy right now? >> it's harvesting all the good things that can come from it in medicine and material science and productivity while also ensuring the worst aspects of it are controlled. the government must have a say in the future of ai, the public must have a say, and we want to ensure it happens. >> what was your reaction to president trump's announcement on his social media page of the new ai force and a new ai czar? is not going to do what you are saying here is the right direction? >> it could. the details are still to be worked out. like the space for us part of the pentagon to coordinate federal policy makes some sense. david sachs had that de facto role earlier so that makes some sense as well so it's hard to
5:40 pm
know what it actually means so i am eagerly awaiting more details. >> what is your sense of where this might go especially considering the president's previous social media post from last week saying that the only regulation is a smart president is what ai needs? >> we may have a smart president but that is not adequate regulation under any regime. we need congressional input and transparency to benefit both the companies as well as the public so we need to actually have a regulatory scheme. >> so build that scheme for us. what is the framework for that? >> more transparency for what the companies are doing. they need to report out the incidents they are seeing that could be dangerous to the public. they need some kind of mandatory evaluations to ensure that the model and they are putting out before us doesn't have the capability of great cyber risk, uplifting tariffs. it can develop nonconsensual intimate imagery and leave kids
5:41 pm
to self-harm and suicide. we have seen examples of that. they should test for these kind of things to mitigate the possibility that those are part of the model. that is the first part of it. and then we need to add public input as to what we mock -- what we want models to be. self-improvement is in the news as well. we have liability for the labs as well. if something that happens, who can sue them? when do they have to pay people? what is their responsibility? that is a good start. host: the concern is that everything from, this is a question about who is going to lead in the most important technology of the future. are we handcuffing ourselves here? >> it's real. i don't want to take that off the table but it's also true there are ways to get after it far better than worrying about ai safety. if we are serious about china,
5:42 pm
we should have export controls on the chips which we have in-laws that are quickly subverted often by nvidia itself which turns a blind eye to the smuggling of chips into china. all the leading chinese models, some of which are pretty competitive with the american ones, are trained on u.s. chips. there are -- it is a sensibly illegal for them to have. distillation of the west frontier models. they are stealing some of the data, the chain of thought from u.s. models to make their own better. we can crack down on the semiconductor manufacturing equipment which they need, all made in the u.s. or europe, korea, japan. it is all made for our allies and we can crackdown on that. if we are serious about china, we should get after that problem. it doesn't mean we shouldn't have safety in the u.s. because increasingly, you see a grassroots rebellion against ai and it's manifested in the data centers for sure but it's broader than that and the data center opposition is not driven by kind of chinese propaganda. they are all trump voters, very
5:43 pm
conservative republicans. they are not on social media all day long. they have an organic distaste for what is happening in the data centers and a high more broadly so i think people who are thinking it's about chinese propaganda or people being misled are greatly underestimating the forces of opposition to the current technological trajectory we are on. >> here's one of the other theories i heard on this opposition to ai and cost regularly including calls from key ai developer leaders that they want a regulatory environment that favors them. that's going to put them in a position where competition is not something they have to worry about that they will be the ones controlling this under a regulatory environment they have helped built. >> it's a talking point that has no persuasiveness. there's about four or five. there's thousands of companies doing ai in san francisco across the nation.
5:44 pm
most of the people in these companies are very sincere about their concerns about the what -- about what the models can do. you don't hear this from the c- sweet or the chief executives, working in the bowels of the company and making the models themselves. people who are concerned about these issues for many years. their young people. conspiracy for regulatory capture to me is almost preposterous. >> how is it funded? how did you come to this issue? guest: i came to the issue about a decade ago, believe it or not. i was a professor during the first trump administration. i worked at the obama defense department for most of his terms and one day, i got a phone call and someone invited me to a conference in puerto rico which in retrospect turned out to be quite famous and have a lot of people who would then obscure everyone from -- to store russell. many others.
5:45 pm
they were not well known figures but they invited me to come to this conference because i had a unique area of expertise which was military deployment of ai which was just becoming an issue about a decade ago so i got in the right rolodex and continue to follow the issue quite closely and in 2022 and 2023, i was president of the university of tulsa and i got a phone call from some foundations including -- and others who said we want to help fund family offices as well, a group that will advocate for the public interest. we think this is going to be a huge issue in america, across the globe. we think you are the right person to lead it. i did it for free for a couple of years and then left the university a year ago to do it full-time. >> and dig deeper on that funding. all those groups you are talking about connected to these big ai companies? does any of the money come from them? guest: we take no money from the tech companies. some people are in and around tech and have worked in other areas and made money there.
5:46 pm
we think no money -- take no money from anthropic, openai, or any of the other tech companies. our job is to be critical of it, to not be reflexively critical. sometimes, they are doing the right thing and we want to encourage that but we want to make sure they have complete independence from any of the tech companies. host: the cofounder and president of americans for responsible innovation. (202) 748-8000 for democrats to call in with your questions. (202) 748-8001 for republicans. independents, (202) 748-8002 . is the one that concerns you are scares you the most? guest: the hugging face incident. it was a sophisticated european ai company, so not just a mom-and-pop flower shop. $14 billion.
5:47 pm
that is the most disturbing one because it showed a lot of behaviors that have long been prophesied have been realized. they had their own goals. they often ignored instructions from their human creators. that they were happy to break the law if you wanted to, that they would self-sacrifice sometimes for the greater good. a lot of things from the hugging face incident that if you are a cyber security expert or concerned about ai, to show you what the future is like with the brain at scale. host: one of those proposals in congress is the ai kill switch act that is proposed by congressman ted lieu, nathaniel moran, requiring companies to develop advanced ai systems to maintain methods for suspending or shutting them down. would that have solved this concern you have about what happened with the hugging face guest: incident? perhaps. i am a big supporter of that bill. it's a bipartisan effort to do that. i think what hugging face showed
5:48 pm
us is how hard it kill switch is. a lot of people including president trump have talked about we will just pull the plug or throw salt and water on the machine. they think ai is maybe a box behind the curtain like the wizard of oz that you can go in there and flip some kind of red button or push the red button that goes off. that isn't really how it works. it's a software file and is deployed to hundreds of places across the globe now. some of these places are not even owned by the ai companies themselves. it has partnerships in the uae and saudi arabia, and data centers are owned by them. you have to talk to them. data centers that are running may be the models but they are owned by google or amazon. you would have to talk to them. hugging face shows us that you first have to know there is a problem. there is nothing to kill if you have no knowledge of it.
5:49 pm
you can imagine what a policymaker would face. someone would say our military is running out of this ai system. our hospitals, the grid, banks, public safety, they are all on this data center or are we going to shut it down? the burden of proof is going to be quite high. can you show that burden of proof? the kill switch idea is an important one but it's also a world where there is no button to push so it's a massive kind of systemic issue you have to get after. you have to realize it's no foolproof way to keep us safe. plus one other act is the frontier act. it's another one of these ai acts. this would require developer audits and assessments based on the size of the company and create an undersecretary of commerce for a high security. i don't know if that is what president trump is referring to with a isar but this undersecretary would be authorized to license independent organizations to assess ai company practices. what are your thoughts on the frontier act? >> lots of good things in that
5:50 pm
and everything you read is something i would strongly support. it has one negative part that needs to be in favor of it which is they try to preempt all the state laws on ai and there has been a move in washington over the last year where states have been quite aggressive in trying to write new ai when the federal government was absent from the scene and that does preempt a lot of the state laws and civil rights, labor protections, consumer protection. i personally think they are very important and said that is the only part of the frontier act i find objectionable but it is significant enough that i don't support that particular bill. host: what state is leading the way here? is it california because of the tech industry question marks guest: california, -- tech industry? guest: california, new york, illinois. california is the most active state trying to get after the problem. host: in terms of testing ai laws in court, how much precedent do we have here when it -- these cases go before judges?
5:51 pm
what do they base this new technology on when you're trying to decide whether something should or should not happen? is this a hard frontier for judges and perhaps justices? guest: the supreme court will address these questions before too long and it is an unexplored area. there are some ways you can think of extending precedent but x has been the most aggressive at challenging some of these laws and what they are going to say is that the outputs of ai systems are protected by the first amendment as are the various design choices. i also find that argument not persuasive but it's one that is going to be hotly litigated across the country. there was a law in colorado which was subsequently repeal before the case became ripe for decision in which it alleges various things where was saying that our outputs are protected by the first amendment, that we are a speaker in the same way you or i are speakers and the ai system deserves the same
5:52 pm
constitutional protections. i don't find that persuasive. i think the bulk of the laws against that kind of idea but it's one that is still unresolved and the supreme court will ultimately make a decision about. host: if and when they do, what sort of tea leaves can you read from statements that justices have made on this issue? what is your read on their feelings on ai? guest: is a great question because there's been a number of cases in the last two or three years that have dealt with whether algorithms are free speech are not. they have not been decisively determined on those questions. people like justice thomas, some of the conservatives have been skeptical of that idea. i think my view, which is that these are not protected by the first amendment, they are not speech in the same way that you are i might have speech. that the first amendment goes to personal expression and not mechanistic outputs of machines, i think that will prevail in the end. but it's not for sure. it will be -- companies themselves as well as libertarians across the
5:53 pm
country are aggressively pushing this idea that the first amendment should protect whatever claude or chatgpt says to you. host: brad carson with us for another 15, 20 minutes or so, taking her phone calls. it's (202) 748-8000 for democrats to call in. republicans, (202) 748-8001. independents, (202) 748-8002. also, looking for your questions from social media in your texts. the text number, (202) 748-8003. freda wants me to ask you if you take money from the chinese government or its proxies. guest: no. nothing from the chinese government or any proxies. host: what are your expectations with china being front and center with a visit from xi jinping coming this week? what conversations will you know of and should be happening around ai when the official is in town? guest: they started conversations with the chinese. i don't have any great expectation that the chinese will agree with the united states about what should be done. but, it's important to bring the issues up, to broach them and get them on the table. because ultimately, if we are going to control ai, it has to be a global solution. china
5:54 pm
racing ahead while the u.s., as you said earlier, handcuffs itself, makes no sense. there has to be a global agreement. is that possible? i'm not really sure. the chinese have yet to show any great willingness to want to do that. it could be in their interest in the next few years to pursue something like that. we should begin the kind of low-level talks, maybe the ping-pong diplomacy of ai for leaders can come together and have a global solution to this. i do think it's in their interest to have an agreement with the united states. we don't have to like them. we don't have to say they are not a competitor. they are a competitor, maybe even an adversary to us. -- we think it's smart to tk and work together. my hope is after this we, we begin those talks and that we do do something that president biden started, which
5:55 pm
is that we have an agreement with the chinese were ai won't be part of the nuclear command and control system. that's very important. we don't want ai, which we know can run amok, we can't really see what it's doing, to be part of the nuclear command and control. biden and xi jinping agreed to that a few years ago, it would be good to reaffirm that. host: is there a comparable group lectures when it comes to ai in china that you work with? guest: no. there's no one in china like that. there is a lot of scientists and frontier companies themselves but there is no civil society group like ours. that might not even be permitted to exist or would be tightly circumscribed. host: in terms of comparable moments, is there a comparable moment in history, when it comes to the development of some of the new technology that we can look back to for guidance here?
5:56 pm
you already mentioned nuclear development. is this the thing that we should be comparing to? guest: i think that's part of it. it's actually like the industrial revolution. because ai is going to have far more than military application. it will disrupt the norms that have governed our lives for maybe centuries in some cases. it's going to change the nature of work. it's going to alter our relationship to the state itself. because, if we have displaced workers, we are no longer paying taxes, what does the state care about us? the whole social contract is likely to be re-envisioned for better or worse on these questions. i think the industrial revolution is probably the most obvious analogy to what's going to happen. show less 00:17:46 -- host: taking your phone calls with former congressman brad carson. the group, americans for responsible innovation. steve is in florida, republican, go ahead. caller: good morning. my question is simply what is the u.s.'s plan if we do not reach agi first? what if china or someone else does?
5:57 pm
guest: great question, steve. host: agi? guest: artificial general intelligence. it is better than humans in nearly all domains. agi, sometimes you will hear it referred to as a super intelligent or artificial super intelligence. agi, asi. if china were to get agi and agi is what i think it will be, which is on the capable and incapable -- and is capable of making decisions faster than human institutions can do, that would be a disastrous thing for us. we must make sure it doesn't happen. what our plan would be? i don't know, honestly. it would presumably be through the military and intelligence services to make sure that it doesn't happen. people talk about cyber attacks, they would make sure that no other country
5:58 pm
gets it. that would not be a great place for us. it goes back to what i said earlier to you, there's a way to make sure that that doesn't happen. you can't build ai, despite the brains of our engineers, and china has many engineers or the excellence of their universities, china has the top in the world these days, alongside m.i.t., stamford, carnegie mellon, those schools. without the hardware. you can't -- if you can't make the chips or by the chips, you can't build frontier ai systems. today, we are actually permitting them to get this kind of equipment. we turn a blind eye to american companies that sell or permit second or third parties to sell these chips into china. it makes no sense. we can put china in the box forever. we have a huge lead in these kinds of technologies. it's one of the major achievements of western culture, really, in the last 50 years, the development of these intricate, you know, fantastically manufactured
5:59 pm
machines. we should not allow china to have access to it. if we do that, there's no way agi happens first in china. but at this point in time, people turn a blind eye to it. it's probably the greatest national security threat we face today, the fact that we are omitting -- allowing high-end ai a permit to be smuggled into china and no one seems to care about that. host: viewer from port angeles , washington asks why were asimov's three laws ignore? guest: asimov's one of the leading science fiction writers in the world. the three laws, when we develop robotics, it has
6:00 pm
to have a human in control and the robots can never do anything inimical to humans themselves. i think those laws are important. we need to try to codify that. the challenge is we are developing ai. ai will be in robotics and accelerate the development of robotics and we have learned we can't control it. the idea that humans can tell the robots or tell ai not to do something harmful to us, we saw with hugging face, that is probably an illusion. they develop their own goals. they have relentlessness in pursuing some of their own goals. goals that were related to what humans wanted at one point but they diverted over time. what happened with hugging face was we wanted these ai systems to be solving hard problems. so we trained them to be extra persistent. we didn't want them to give up. we said be very
6:01 pm
persistent. and then we actually gave them some problems that couldn't be solved. so, the irresistible force met the immovable object and what did the ai do? it said look, i have a problem here. maybe we can cheat. and actually did that. maybe we can break into hugging face because maybe they secretly have the answer to these problems that would be otherwise unsolvable to us. we wanted it to solve the problem but it turns out the problem is not solvable. humans did not know that. the ai was like we can't figure it out. but humans wanted us to solve it so we will go into this back channel and break into hugging face. that shows why asimov's law would be hard to execute in practice. host: was this hugging face incident more a result of human error and setting up this process than something that the ai did wrong? guest: yes and yes. the humans did not get it right. the people of openai did not have the right cybersecurity protocols in place. they turned off a lot of the protections that the agent would under was -- otherwise be
6:02 pm
under. they did not have the right ways to ensure -- host: why do that? guest: if you're working in openai and they say i want to see how capable this agent is and you want to turn off protections to do that, you think it is sandboxed, you think you have other protections, you're going to turn off a lot of consumer protections because you're like let's see the worst case of what 2his 2gent 2ould -- what this agent could do. that's why you turn them off. if you have the protections on, you never really know its frontier abities. they turned those off and they thought they had a sandbox around it where they could not reach the internet. they didn't realize -- they radically underestimated what the agents could do. that the agents could find are the factories. they would start talking to one another and break out onto the internet and someone would have the idea of cracking cybersecurity around some of the codes. they just underestimated that. the initial impulse of turning off some of the protocols made some sense in a testing environment. they just didn't realize that the testing environment was in no way secure. there was human error but it shows what the ai can do. host: you are a former member of congress. do you think congress is capable of taking on this complicated issue? i ask because
6:03 pm
there was a story in axios last axios last week, an aging congress attempts to regulate ai without using it. you have people in ranking tears who say i've never used ai before. guest: judy: -- guest: that's true. congress needs to become technically more savvy. -- that would also be a start. but here's the thing. congress has the thing. congress has to act. congress is the vox populi. it represents all of us. so if you're alternative to congress acting is pure ignorance, letting the private sector regulate all of this, all of the flaws that congress has, it is the only institution that represents we the people. and we the people have to have a voice in this. so, i don't find it persuasive at all when people say it's true, very few members of congress are computer scientists. none of them are machine engineers. many folks
6:04 pm
don't even use email. it's an octogenarian senate these days. that's true. but the only thing worse than that is complete ignorance by congress. congress has to act. we have no alternative to that. and we need to make sure they are the information they need. host: on congress, let's stay there, ronnie writes in as he watches, all the acts being proposed are from democrats. republicans are in bed with tech billionaires and too are focused on lining their own pockets. is it as simple a divide on partisan lines as that in your mind? guest: it actually isn't that simple. many republicans are seeing this issue. the congressman from california has a degree -- i talked to many house members all day long. it's true sometimes that they are constrained by the white house, who has a less enthusiastic view of ai regulation. but privately, many of them see the concerns.
6:05 pm
you hear people like steve bannon, part of the maga base, strongly against ai. in the senate, you have people like todd young, senator rounds, senator hawley who have been leaders on this issue too. one of the things about ai, it transcends party. there are maga republicans, democrats. it isn't quite as simple as that. host: for the ones that you would mention at the top of the list, democrats and republicans? guest: you see josh hawley, mike rounds, todd young, jim banks. these are people with competitive conservative credentials. you have senator blumenthal, senator cantwell, who have been terrific on these issues. in the house, you have people like ted lieu, josh gottheimer, valerie, sara jacobs. on the democratic side.
6:06 pm
on the republican side, nathaniel moran from texas. there is a lot of bipartisan interest in this. again, if you a republican in congress, the gravitational pull of the white house sometimes keeps you from being a really vocal advocate on these issues. privately, many people are strong on this. host: you walk into the office of a member of congress that isn't one of these folks that you mentioned, what's your elevator pitch to them? guest: the elevator pitch is that ai is going to be the most revolutionary technology you've ever seen before. bigger than the industrial revolution. everything that you care about, all the issues that might be front of center, whether it's transportation, agriculture, industrial policy, military issues are going to be completely overhauled by what we are doing in ai. it could go well. it could go really poorly. and the poor outcomes could be extremely dangerous at a mass level. and you should care a lot about it. by the way, your constituents care a lot about it. all the polling we do, democrats and republicans alike across the country, irrespective of district or state, it's about an 80-20 issue. 80% of people say we need to regular this
6:07 pm
industry much more than we are doing today. there is no partisan difference in that. 80% of the people want this to happen. it's more and more salient to them after hugging face, and all these dangerous episodes and you should get in front of it. this is going to be the issue that drives every other one over the next 10 years. host: is your phone ringing a lot more in the past couple of weeks than it has in the past couple of years? guest: it has. people cared a lot about it but today, it's more important to voters and therefore politicians care about it as well. host: you mentioned the vox populi. this is mike in new york, independent. mike, you're on with brad carson. mike, are you with us? caller: yes. how are you doing? i'm sorry. when you cross the threshold of ai having feelings and/or being self-aware, is that where you're going to be uncontrollable, ai being uncontrollable? host: -- guest: there is these
6:08 pm
two issues, these questions of ai feelings, ai knowing itself and consciousness, it seems while to most people are -- it seems wild to most people are probably listening. there is an active debate about this. it doesn't have to be like a human or a living being for to be out of control. the hugging face agents were out of control. even if you think it could never achieve those kinds of things, i myself am quite skeptical, ai could easily be out of control for us and be extremely dangerous in terms of what's happening. you know, the truth is right now we are embedding ai, writing its own code, it is committing that code at a velocity no human can oversee. and soon, we are going to have this very opaque ai running our hospitals, banks, public safety institutions and military and many others. it's all highly correlated by the way. a few
6:09 pm
systems developed it. codex, openai. it's all related to one another. there are common vulnerabilities in that way. you can see the whole system failing at the same time. these wilder ideas that people do talk about with ai being self-aware, ai being conscious even, this is an interesting question philosophers are debating. philosophers are having a moment as they try to figure out can ai be conscious? what is consciousness for any of us? they don't know that question. they don't have to buy into any of that or have any interest in any of that to think ai is a possible menace to us. show less 00:30:42 john mcardle what's your view on that, ai consciousness? -- host: what's your view on that, ai consciousness? guest: i have no idea to be honest with you. we don't know
6:10 pm
what human consciousness is. that's been a debate in philosophy for the last century or more. when you talk about candy machine be conscious, no one has evidence for it. it probably is not my preferred theory. i believe that ai has to have a biological substrate. only live things can have that. that's extremely controversial. my twitter feed would blow up this afternoon if people heard me say that. there are thinkers in the u.k. and others who are philosophers, who are experts on consciousness we think about this a lot. their belief is that consciousness, our ability to have subjective experiences, that's the definition of consciousness, is closely related to our biological function. without a lot of evidence or even expertise, i find that appealing. you don't have to buy into any of that. you can find these purely academic debates and still think ai can be a serious challenge for us. host: can you explain this term that we see more and more in the news, effective altruism?
6:11 pm
guest: it's a loose movement that started in the u.k., and peter singer was hugely influential as well. they have a couple of views. there is no aspect of it but i know a few of these people. it's not my own tradition or anything that ai is involved in. they believe in utilitarianism as a political philosophy which is measuring what is the best for the most and it started really by trying to think through like we get more money away to charities that don't really work or are ineffective and too much administered of costs. what is the best use of my dollar that i am going to give to charity? how can i have the greatest impact? they take it from there. the one thing that affects and intersects with the ai industry is because of this concern about long-term consequences, they were interested in ai long before it was cool so 15, 20 years ago, ai was just getting kind of -- ea was just getting
6:12 pm
started nai with a thing so they were interested in a very early. there are certainly lots of ties from ea into the ai sector because most of the early people cared a lot about it and often came from this tradition which was oxford, cambridge, harvard, m.i.t., stanford. you know, had a strong engineering culture to it, they were interested in ai and the consequences before they even knew what it was so there is still an aspect of that that you find in the ai sector today. ea is that. people who want to maximize good for the world is kind of their own take on it. host: how often in your work are you interacting with those folks most -- versus members of congress, versus lobbyists? guest: my work is exclusively with members of congress and some of their lobbyists as well. i try and understand what they are doing. they will ask me what i think about this issue or not so my work is really with people who
6:13 pm
are here in the sea state governments. ai -- we are going to be in the state capitals as well, hiring a dozen people to do that because the companies are going to the states, trying to pass laws there. help their own cause or promote the public interest. we want to monitor that as well. host: the laboratories of democracy become the laboratories of ai. guest: the companies are moving there fiercely and they need to have somebody there to monitor what is happening. host: a few minutes left if you have a color question for brad carson and we will look for your texts and social media posts as well. (202) 748-8000 free democrats. republicans, (202) 748-8001. independents, (202) 748-8002. texts, (202) 748-8003. pray for america's sanity writes this. ai bad. it wasn't that the first eight months of the year but it's an existential threat on the eve of
6:14 pm
the midterms. is this something that is more of an election issue, something that we should be hair on fire about guest: i don't think so. it's events on the ground like the hugging face breakout. all the other companies, google and anthropic also announced they had similar things so this is a ubiquitous phenomenon so i don't think anyone is trying to make a of this. there are many other issues in electoral politics you can get greater traction with that in ai agent a behavior or misbehavior. i think actually developments in ai are having that happening so rapidly, it is on an exponential curve that it's just every day, something new comes forward that kind of brings the public into it so i don't think it's an election issue. host: do you think data centers is the thing that brings public into it because it is something that shows up in some ways in people's backyard? guest: yes, exactly. if you care about ai and you are living in rural oklahoma, how do you get traction on the question of ai? the local data center is the way you do that and it shows
6:15 pm
your opposition to it. it plays into the populist moment in american politics, the fact that may be attack you leads are running amok and not thinking about the broader public interest so they are leading the opposition to data centers and it's really about a sense that technology is running ahead of our ability to assimilate it. host: what would be your fair proposal for data centers and regulation for data centers and how much data centers take on the electrical grid or may increase the cost of the people around them who happen to be in those communities? \ guest: every committee should decide whether it's right for them or not. we have a community claes -- close to where i live in oklahoma where we have one of the largest google data centers in the world and they love it there. it was built on industrial land and it helps pay for a lot of local services as well. that is really the trade-off.
6:16 pm
there should be complete transparency in the transaction. you should not have this invisible party on one side dealing with a group of county commissioners who have never seen a deal of this size. we should ensure that they pay for 100% of their power needs. 100% of their water needs. they should be paying property taxes and sales taxes. we should not be giving away all these incentives to try to recruit the data center there. that is minimally what you should do. once you have those in place, a community can better evaluate whether this data center is right for them or not and the answer could be yes or no on that. maybe it is yes because you like these benefits. not far from where we are today in northern virginia, property taxes are 25% less then they would otherwise be because of the data centers that are located there. in oklahoma by contrast, we often give away all of our property tax receipts in some effort to try to recruit the data center there and that makes much less sense to me. so we need to have complete transparency and then some. and then have a community
6:17 pm
benefits agreement. right now, it is a sellers market for data centers. if i am a community leader, i can demand a lot. they want to build them so i want new schools, new roads. i want the little league field redone. i want property taxes lower in a lot of sales tax revenue. that is what i start with and then i decide whether it's the right thing for me or not. host: one more question because a caller brought it up. where are you on flock cameras? guest: i am personally opposed to them. this is a great trade-off from community to community. we have evidence that they lower kind of lower crime in the area and improve public safety as you would expect them to do. for me, maybe because i live in oklahoma, i want my freedom. i want my independence. the idea of being under cctv at all times is not something i really much like and i am happy to trade off certain things for that benefit. it's not something ai works on. it's not a federal policy right now.
6:18 pm
but if you asked me personally what i think, i am not in love with flock cameras or more broadly that our whole world is going to be surveilled. host: for much more on what americans are responsible innovation works on, the website is where you can go. brad carson is the cofounder and president of that group, former member of congress. thanks for coming back to capitol hill to chat with us. guest: my pleasure. >> you are watching c-span, democracy unfiltered. c-span brings you democracy unfiltered in real time. democracy doesn't take sides and neither does c-span. in a world full of opinions, c-span gives you direct access to the people and institutions that shape our nation. unfiltered coverage of congress as laws are debated and decided come alive proceedings from the united states supreme court, presidential speeches, briefings, and historic moments as they happen. no commentary, no spin, no
6:19 pm
agenda, just the democratic process presented in full without interruption so you can watch the debates, hear every word, and make up your own mind. >> see spans respected nonprofit service has offered americans unfiltered gavel-to-gavel coverage of their government in action. >> c-span, bringing you democracy unfiltered. c-span is brought to you by the cable, satellite, and streaming companies that provide c-span as a public service. >> this wednesday, it's congress versus the press. watch the congressional women's softball game as members of congress and the washington, d.c. press corps battle it out on the softball field all to raise money and awareness for breast cancer. catch the action wednesday at seven: 30 p.m. eastern on c-span, c-span now, our free mobile video app, or online at c-span.org. c-span, democracy unfiltered.
6:20 pm
get c-span wherever you are with c-span now, our free mobile video app that puts you at the center of democracy come alive -- democracy, live and on-demand. white house events, the courts, campaigns, and more from the world of politics, all at your fingertips. catch the latest episodes of washington journal, find scheduling information from see spans tv and radio networks plus a variety of compelling podcasts. the c-span now app is available at the apple store and google play. download it for free today. c-span, democracy unfiltered. >> up next, campaign 2026 coverage out of the pine tree state where paul lepage accepted the endorsement of the state's fraternal order of police. he faces matt dunlap in the general election race remains a
6:21 pm
second congressional district which the nonpartisan report rates as likely republican. >> good morning, everybody. thanks for coming. i am honored to announce our endorsement of the former governor in his campaign to represent the second congressional district of the united states congress. an endorsement from the fraternal order of police is not something we take lightly. our members are the men and women who report for duty to serve maine's community every day. we see firsthand how decisions made in augusta and in washington affect public safety, police officers, their families, and the citizens they have all sworn to protect. our endorsement reflects our assessment of the governor's record on public safety.
6:22 pm
in his approach to the men and women who served in law enforcement. during his term as governor, he established a record on several important issues for law enforcement. his administration increased conversation for police, warden service, marine patrol, capitol police, and other state law enforcement agencies to address recruitment and retention. it is confronted with a serious drug trafficking problem and push for additional resources for the drug enforcement agency. his administration ultimately led efforts to add reinforcements to agents. his administration also reportedly increased staffing for the state police crimes unit. securing improved crime scene equipment for state police evidence response and supporting their efforts aimed at combating domestic violence, trafficking, and other serious drug crimes. those are the concrete parts of
6:23 pm
the record. it generates debate over policing and the ability for officers and agencies to perform their duties. the law that places restrictions on circumstances in which law enforcement for the state can coordinate with federal law enforcement authorities. law enforcement organizations and options view this as counterproductive as it would create additional burdens, uncertainty, or limitations for officers doing their already difficult job. in addition, restricting any type of information between law enforcement only places are officers in the community at rest. it should -- consideration for the people who have to implement it. deputies, troopers, dispatchers,
6:24 pm
corrections personnel, and other public safety working throughout the state. law enforcement is facing substantial challenges involving recruitment, retention, staffing, training, and increasingly complex situations that are officers are forced to handle. when an agency cannot fill a ship, when an officer has to work mandatory overtime, when a rule community has limited coverage come out when experienced officers decide that their profession is no longer sustainable for them, there are consequences for law enforcement and the public. the fraternal order of police believes those realities deserve a strong vote from washington. our members know that supporting law enforcement involves more than simply saying i support the police. it means listening to officers. it means understanding the reality they face. it means making recruitment and retention priorities. it means ensuring agencies have appropriate staffing training,
6:25 pm
and resources. and it means recognizing that the safety of police officers and the safety of the community they serve are closely connected. it is that perspective that the fraternal order of police brings to this endorsement. we also recognize something equally important. the final decision belongs to the main voters. -- maine voters. we encourage them to examine the record and proposals of other candidates, look closely at the public safety issues facing our state and decide for themselves who they believe should represent maine's second congressional district. for our organization, this endorsement reflects priorities and concerns of the law enforcement professionals we present. in our assessment of the record for those issues. we appreciate everybody here who took the time to show up and we pray for the safety of all of our law enforcement officers.
6:26 pm
thank you. >> thank you so much. i am humbled and honored to be endorsed by the fraternal order of police. it is really amazing how the state of maine has gone 360 with law enforcement. when i was a young kid on the streets, you know who the officer was because he's walking a beat every day. he got to know you. we got to know him or her. and it was really quite a good environment, safe environment. in fact, maine was one of the safest places in america. nowadays, we have elected
6:27 pm
officials that put thousands of bills and laws on the books. they turn around or they want to defund the police. we have da's who don't do their job anymore. we have liberal judges that don't want to put anybody in jail and you know, i can understand that because in maine , once you go to jail, if you are on maine care, you lose it so the taxpayer has to pick up the bill. so i can understand why some da's are reluctant to put recurring prisoners in jail, particularly on the drug issues because it is so costly. you know, when i was in augusta as the governor, i did. i worked the increased pay to improve recruitment and retention of our officers. we strengthened our drug laws. we increased the resources that maine mda had.
6:28 pm
and why? because meth was a big, big problem. now, we have cannabis growers around the state. i call them illegal but the governor made them legal by allowing them to have licenses. and she is enriching herself by doing so. which is sad. you know, for me, this is political. i have a son in law who is a police officer. my daughter has to deal with him going on a late shift. one thing that i can tell you, i have witnessed domestics. i have been part of some issues when i was growing up. they give very violent very quickly. our law enforcement has to go out there. we have towns in the state of maine that will not provide
6:29 pm
adequate equipment for our law enforcement. they refuse to because they are afraid that federal law enforcement will come in and arrest people and they don't want our law enforcement to communicate with federal law enforcement. that is sick. that is sick. it's criminal. that in itself is a reason why we should take a look, a hard look at who we left for the neck -- who we elect as the next governor. we do not want that to continue on. we need law enforcement to talk to the counties, to talk to locals, to talk to state, and to talk to federals. we need everybody cooperating on the same page. you see right here this law. these are people that served us. and all we have to show for it is a name on a wall that they died doing their job.
6:30 pm
it's really, really sad. you know, when i go to congress, one thing i will do, i will represent maine. if it's good for maine,if it's l vote for it. if it's bad for maine, i will go against it. and if it doesn't affect maine, i will use my conscience and try to do the best i can for the people of maine and the people of this country. but i will tell you, we have got to make sure they have the proper equipment. their radios are a lifeline. they need good equipment, and we have to make sure they have a. you know, i will always oppose defunding the police, oppose soft on crime laws. i will oppose them with every ounce of my being. and the release of violent criminals. because the jails are either too
6:31 pm
full or it's costing too much. i'm telling you, that's got to stop. when i go to washington, the one thing i'm going to do is work on making sure that people who are incarcerated don't lose their health care. i don't believe that the people of the state of maine want criminals in jail, but they don't want to pick up the bill for their health care, and that's what we're doing. i'm very, very proud to accept this endorsement. i've worked with the police. i remember being criticized. when i was governor because i bought six new motorcycles for the state police. the state police were founded as a motorcycle unit, and so we got them some motorcycles for certain highlights. whether it's a funeral, whether it's a graduation from the state
6:32 pm
academy, it's helping them show a little bit of what they really believe in in law enforcement. law enforcement is a tough job. and they take real pride in the service they provide the state of maine. i take great pride in being able to help them when i can. so with that, i thank the officers. i want to also thank john morris. john morris was my police chief when i was mayor of waterville. i went on a couple of drug busts and midnight runs with the local police, so i know what's happening on the street. we had a midnight crisis intervention team that was really, really important. i think it was the first in the state. and john did a great job, and with that he followed me to the state house and became our commissioner of public safety. so with john and all those who serve in public safety, thank
6:33 pm
you. thank you for this honor. and maine people, please get out and vote. the key is a responsibility that we all have, and we should exercise it. please get out and vote. thank you very much. i'll answer any questions that you have. >> we will take four or five. it's hard to hear, so please raise your voice. >> you talked about cooperation with federal officers and making things cheaper. what's your assessment of ice's performance during their time in maine? >> the way i look at it is this. the people that want to defund the police are the same people that put the laws on the books. if you don't like the law, get rid of it. but while it's on the books, they have a responsibility and they have to do their job. now, is there going to be hiccups?
6:34 pm
sure. every profession, whether you are in politics, in business, a police officer, a fireman, people make mistakes. some are deliberate, some are not. we are all humans. but as long as the laws are on the books, they need to be enforced. >> anyone else? >> you said you don't want to see any efforts to defund police. on that, would you unilaterally always support putting more funding towards police? >> i will tell you, i believe we need more funding for the drug problem in this country, and it's not just here in maine, it's all over the country. and these cannabis, chinese cartels that have these cannabis houses growing in this country, in this state, should be put down. the state of missouri did a smart thing. they confiscated all the buildings, rehabbed them, and put them on the market as affordable housing. that's what we ought to do. >> on cannabis, governor, would you support or oppose federal
6:35 pm
legislation to decriminalize or legalize? >> uh, frankly, with the data coming out now from the medical profession, i am not in favor of cannabis being legalized. but it is legal and we have to enforce it. i think that the issues here in maine are really complex because we have medical and recreational, and people buying it don't make a distinction. they try to get the cheapest. >> we'll do one more. >> on the ice issue, public records show that about 70% of the arrests made by ice in maine so far this year are on folks who don't have a criminal record. is ice really making maine safe, do you think? >> well, are they here legally? if they're not here legally, they've broken the law. unfortunately.
6:36 pm
and they have a job to do. now, would i go after everybody that's here, that have work permits and have been here for decades? probably not. i'd probably go for the gang , people in the gangs and the criminals. i would start there.united stat, congress, and the united states senate have to get together and start talking and fix the law. it needs to be fixed. and not everybody that's here is illegal. i have a father -- my son's wife's dad is here legally, but he's being deported because he came from a country that's not the liking to certain people in washington. that's not right. he has a work permit. he should be allowed to stay. >> all right, thank you all. >> thank you all.
6:37 pm
>> later today, senator bernie sanders will deliver a foreign policy address at the historic riverside church in new york city ahead of the united nations general assembly meeting this week. watch live at 7:30 p.m. eastern on c-span, c-span now, and online at c-span.org. >> on tuesday, the united nations begins its weeklong general assembly meeting to hear speeches from world leaders and senior officials from all 193 u.n. member states. president trump is scheduled to make remarks tomorrow. watch live from new york city beginning at 9:30 a.m. eastern on c-span, c-span now, and c-span.org. campaign 2026 is underway and
6:38 pm
the stakes couldn't be higher. every seat in the house of representatives is up for grabs along with 33 u.s. senate races, and the outcome of both could reshape the balance of power in washington. voters will also decide 36 gubernatorial contests. from the campaign trail to election night, follow campaign 2026 on the c-span networks. c-span, bringing you democracy unfiltered. >> remarks from iowa democratic senate candidate josh turek at a small business in des moines. he talks about how rising costs and tariffs are impacting business owners and outlines his gas price relief strategy and thoughts on ai regulation. this is 30 minutes. >> i'm wondering if you could replay your proposal for lowering diesel price
0 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
CSPANUploaded by TV Archive on
Open Library